Good Communication Requires Agreement with the Message – True or False?

Effective communication is essential for success in both personal and professional relationships. The ability to convey ideas, thoughts, and feelings requires not only good communication skills but also an understanding of the message being conveyed. So, does good communication require agreement with the message? The answer to this question is both true and false.


When it comes to delivering a message, good communication requires that the message is clear, concise, and well-articulated. The person delivering the message should ensure that the message is understood by the recipient, and they should facilitate the discussion to ensure that the message is received. In this context, good communication may require agreement with the message.

For instance, when a health care provider delivers a diagnosis, it is necessary that the patient understands the message. The provider may need to explain the diagnosis in simple terms, so it is easy for the patient to understand. The patient may have questions or concerns, which the provider may need to address effectively. If the patient does not understand or agree with the diagnosis, it may lead to miscommunication and poor health outcomes.


However, good communication does not always require agreement with the message. People may have different perspectives, opinions, and beliefs. Disagreements are a natural part of communication and can lead to positive outcomes. In fact, disagreements can lead to a deeper understanding of the issue at hand.

For example, in a business setting, team members may have different opinions on how to approach a project. Each person may have unique insights, ideas, and perspectives. By sharing their views and engaging in dialogue, the team can arrive at a more comprehensive solution. It is not necessary that every team member agrees with the final outcome, as long as everyone can communicate effectively and work towards a common goal.


In conclusion, good communication requires both clarity and understanding of the message being conveyed. While agreement with the message may be essential in some situations, it is not always necessary for effective communication. The ability to engage in dialogue, respect differences, and work towards common goals is the hallmark of good communication. As communicators, we should strive to communicate effectively, even in situations where agreement is not possible.